Ethnicity Pay Reporting – Guidance for Employers
The ethnicity pay gap is the difference between the average earnings of white employees and those of other ethnic groups.
As things stand, there is a disparity between the treatment of gender and ethnicity-based pay inequalities. Whilst companies with 250 or more employees have had to publish their gender pay gap since 2017, reporting their ethnicity pay gap remains voluntary.
Yet, we know an ethnicity pay gap persists. For example, in 2022, UK-born Black, African, Caribbean or Black British employees earned 5.6% less than UK-born White employees, according to the ONS. This gap has not changed since 2012.
While there are no current plans to make ethnicity pay gap reporting mandatory for UK employers, that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t consider doing it. Many organisations have started publishing this information alongside their gender pay gap reporting and it is backed by both the CIPD and the government as something that, while voluntary, can add a lot of value to your business. Shining a light on pay disparities is a helpful first step to addressing inequalities in the workplace.
So, why should you consider voluntarily measuring and addressing your Ethnicity Pay Gap?
1. Prospect of expected legislation changes
As part of a broader plan to tackle racial inequality, the current administration has indicated that they will extend mandatory reporting requirements to include ethnicity pay. Therefore, it makes sense for employers to get ahead of the curve and take steps now to assess whether there may be legal risks they want to address and opportunities for change.
2. Risk mitigation against legal claims
After mandatory gender pay gap reporting was introduced in 2017, there was an increase in equal pay claims. In recent years, there has been a rise in race discrimination claims citing salary inequalities. The number of these cases in anticipated to increase, particularly if ethnicity pay gap reporting becomes mandatory.
It is important to note that, strictly speaking, equal pay legislation relates only to comparisons between the pay for men and women. Unequal pay between men and women doing substantially the same work can be challenged accordingly. There is no equal pay legislation, as such, applicable between different ethnic groups. However, pay disparity between different ethnic groups may be indicative of unlawful race discrimination and may be open to challenge under the Equality Act 2020.
Conducting an internal ethnicity pay gap audit can assist your organisation in identifying possible vulnerabilities and areas of exposure. The findings can inform the development of a strategy and timeframe for change, with measurable goals and actions.
3. Stakeholder interest
Clients, investors, regulators and future job candidates increasingly assess companies on their Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) credentials. ESG initiatives are essential to successful financial performance, brand reputation and attracting investment. These may include Diversity, Equity & Inclusion (DEI) policies and practices. Employers may decide that publishing an ethnicity pay gap report and action plan is one way of signifying their values to their stakeholders.
4. Correlation between diversity and prosperity
There is a proven business case for DEI. A report by McKinsey found that diversity on executive teams increases the likelihood of financial outperformance. It has been demonstrated time and again that diverse-led organisations are:
- Thirty-nine percent more likely to outperform those lacking diversity
- Twelve times more likely to engage and retain employees
- Nearly eight and a half times more likely to inspire a sense of belonging
- Eight and a half times more likely to satisfy and retain customers
The McGregor-Smith review suggests that addressing race inequalities in the labour market could boost the UK economy by £24 billion a year.
Reporting on your ethnicity pay gap will support you with reviewing ethnicity representation across your organisation. As well, understand whether you are diverse in your hiring practices, and if your organisation attracts diverse applicants. If not, then you can identify the reasons why. It can help open up conversations and put in place strategies to improve your recruitment practices and recognise gaps.
5. Talent attraction
It has been reported that up to 96% of employees expect their employer to adopt a sustainability agenda but less than one-third of HR leaders prioritise sustainability and ESG. KPMG research also found that one in three Gen Z workers have rejected a job offer if an employer’s ESG values did not align with their own.
In an increasingly competitive market, pay gap reporting can demonstrate your organisation’s commitment to fairness and equity. It will also create visibility, showcasing you as a forward-thinking organisation and highlighting how seriously you take action on diversity and inclusion.
6. Enhanced organisational trust
Employee perception of pay equity is based on organisational trust. However, Business Leader reported that only around one-third of employees believe their pay is equitable, and less than one-third believe they are fairly compensated for their work. Furthermore, in the UK, only one quarter of employees trust their leadership.
Voluntary ethnicity pay gap reporting can help to build trust and promote transparency.
In Summary
Ethnicity pay gap reporting is a vital step towards achieving pay equity which offers numerous benefits for employers.
While it is not yet mandatory, why wouldn’t you do everything in your power to be transparent and build an ethical and equitable organisation that can attract top talent and may just help you retain your best employees?
If you already report on gender pay, then you will likely have a workable framework that you can use as a basis for your ethnicity pay reporting. It will enable you to identify any pertinent differences across your pay and, backed by data, put in place strategies and timeframes to implement change, if needed, or celebrate equality in your workplace.
Employers who grasp the nettle and start making strides towards transparency in ethnicity pay will undoubtedly reap the benefits.
Need help with your pay gap reporting?
At Turning Point, we can work with you to review and analyse your ethnicity pay data and support you in making meaningful organisational change. We have a wealth of experience and can help guide you to the best solution for your organisation and people.
If you have any questions about pay gap reporting or need help with any aspect of your pay and reward strategy, please contact our team of reward specialists by emailing us at info@turningpointhr.com
Skip to content