Is Your Salary Benchmarking Data Compliant?

In a landmark decision last month, more than 3,500 current and former Next employees won a six-year equal pay action against the store, which experts say could “shine a light” on gender segregation in the private sector and have serious ramifications for future cases.

An employment tribunal ruled that store staff, who are predominantly women, should not have been paid less than their male counterparts working in the company’s warehouses.

This ruling marks a significant victory in the fight for equal pay, with the potential back-pay owed to these workers exceeding £30 million. The case highlights the ongoing issue of gender pay disparity, particularly in sectors where certain roles are predominantly occupied by women.

Next argued at the hearing in May of this year that market forces explained the pay difference and warehouse roles generally command higher wages in the broader job market compared to retail roles. However, the tribunal rejected this justification, setting a precedent that could impact similar disputes across other sectors.

What this means for your business

Equal pay claims are likely to continue to make the headlines in the retail sector for the foreseeable future. There are similar long-running equal pay cases pending against other large retailers such as Tesco, Sainsbury’s, Asda and Morrisons.

While retail is currently the key battleground, the success of the Next claimants may encourage employees in other sectors to consider equal pay claims. Education, finance & insurance, and construction have some of the worst imbalances, according to gender pay gap reporting figures, so it is vital businesses get their pay equity in order.

Is your data good enough?

Market data is mentioned in the Equality Act 2010 as a non-discriminatory rationale to differ between jobs of a similar weight within organisations, so long as the data is free of discrimination. The law firm representing the workers argued that the market data used in the data survey was in itself discriminatory – thereby perpetuating gender pay differentials.

This clearly underlines the need to ensure that any market data you rely on to differentiate between roles in your organisation MUST be free of any discriminatory aspects (such as a high percentage of female post holders) to ensure you remain compliant with the Act.

What is compliant, robust data?

Using unverified data from unknown sources will leave you open to falling foul of this new ruling. You need to be sure that any data you are relying on is free from any unintended bias. This would include using data with an uneven gender balance within its content. An example would be using comparator data from an organisation that has a significant makeup of employees from a specific gender that would weight the outcomes in such a manner as to perpetuate inequalities against any protected characteristic.

Should you use data from a comparator organisation that can be shown to have been non-compliant with the Equality Act and / or has been successfully ruled against at an Employment Tribunal, you run the risk of falling foul of the law, just as Next seemingly have done.

Getting on top of pay equity

Employers can mitigate the risk of litigation by reviewing their approach to salary benchmarking and conducting an equal pay audit.

However, the best defence against an equal pay claim is to carry out a job evaluation project. This will assess the content of jobs across the workforce by reference to their core components including skill, effort and responsibility. This allows employers to identify roles of equal value to ensure that individuals across those different roles are paid equally.

In Summary

Pay equity has long been a challenge for businesses. However, the Next case could serve as a catalyst for other companies to address their own pay equity issues. Now is the time to acknowledge and resolve any pay gaps within your organisation and work towards achieving true equity for your business and employees.

Need help with your pay and reward strategy?

At Turning Point, we have significant experience in facilitating comprehensive Equal Pay Audits and have specific expertise in salary benchmarking, job evaluation and equal pay matters.

Contact our team to find out more about how we can work with you to ensure fairness is at the heart of your remuneration approach.

More News

5 Ways to Keep Your Job Architecture Relevant and Effective

Many organisations have invested time and effort in developing a job architecture. The challenge is ensuring it remains relevant once the initial project has been completed. Too often, job architecture is treated as a one-off exercise. Roles are evaluated, a framework is established, and new roles are simply slotted in over time. However, for job architecture to deliver lasting value, it must evolve with the organisation. Keeping it up to date doesn't need to be arduous. A well-managed framework can ...
Read More →

Autumn Budget 2026: What It Means for Employers

Chancellor John Healey has delivered the Autumn Budget 2026. While there were no major surprises on employment taxation, the Budget contains several announcements that will affect workforce costs, reward strategies and employee expectations. Key themes include continued upward pressure on pay, growing momentum behind pay transparency, and additional support measures aimed at working families and carers.   National Living Wage and National Minimum Wage increase The National Living Wage and National Minimum Wage will increase by 3.9% from April 2027, ...
Read More →

The Evolution of Orbit™: Building the Foundations for Equitable and Explainable Reward

One of the things I've always enjoyed about working in technology is finding ways to make complex processes simpler and more consistent. Spreadsheets have their place. So does AI. The challenge is knowing what each does well, where human judgement must remain involved, and how technology can make life easier for HR and Reward teams without creating another system to feed, fix and explain. One connected platform Orbit™ began as a job evaluation tool. Today, it has evolved into a ...
Read More →