Redhill Academy Trust
Job Evaluation and Salary Benchmarking
The Client
Redhill Academy Trust is a thriving and ambitious community of schools providing education for children and young people across Nottinghamshire and Derbyshire. The Multi-Academy Trust (MAT) encompasses 16 academies, educating over 11,000 children in nursery, infant, junior, secondary and post-16 settings.
The Challenge
Redhill Academy Trust employs approximately 400 non-teaching staff in approximately 90 roles. The trust wished to ensure that all employee remuneration meets UK legislative status.
Nottinghamshire Council had undergone a pay and grading review involving the use of Job Evaluation under the Single Status Agreement.
On transfer to Academy status, the unions had signed up to Redhill employing Job Evaluation as a method by which equal pay / equal value issues could be identified and rectified. The unions had agreed to postpone any equal pay action, so long as Redhill carried out the majority of this evaluation process by an agreed date.
Redhill Academy, as a foundation school, wanted to adopt a different approach to their pay and grading to underpin their new status.
The Solution
A meeting was held between the key stakeholders of the Academy and Turning Point at which the project scope and outcomes were agreed. Timeframes and project milestones, along with a communication strategy, were agreed against a tight schedule in order to comply with union undertakings.
Once all objectives were signed off, the first element of the project was communication. Organisations cannot over communicate when it comes to matters involving pay. A series of staff forums were arranged to ensure that all post holders, full and part time, had an opportunity to attend. The forums were used to explain what was to happen and how, and the impact on each staff member. Equally, the forums focused on providing reassurance and explaining what was not going to happen, i.e. mass redundancies, huge pay cuts (or rises), and the various other scenarios that can grow in a communication vacuum.
As part of the Job Evaluation process, each post holder was given the opportunity to fill out a Job Description questionnaire designed to allow the post holder to explain what they do in their role at the Academy. These questionnaires were then used, in conjunction with up-to-date, approved Job Descriptions, by the Job Evaluation panel.
The Job Evaluation panel consisted of 3 post holders from the Academy, chosen for their knowledge of specific areas of the organisation. These areas included Teaching Assistants, Technicians and Administrative staff. The Business Manager of the Academy was also part of the Evaluation panel, which was chaired by Turning Point.
Using Turning Point’s proprietary Job Evaluation scheme (JOES), the roles were evaluated individually and placed in a rank order of internal relativity, as defined by the criteria of the evaluation scheme. This rank order was then used to inform an external pay benchmarking process against local comparators within a 20-mile radius of Nottingham. Comparators included the Local Authority, but also private sector organisations.
The Academy wished to pay ‘above the median’ for certain roles and the benchmark data was used to inform what value the median was for each role. A pay framework was then designed which was based on the concept of spots and ranges. Each discrete job role had its own range with 5 zones within it.
The first zone was positioned below the median and would be used to ‘on board’ individuals for probationary periods. The second zone, the spot, was positioned at the median with the three remaining zones being positioned at percentages above the median.
The outcomes of the evaluation and pay benchmarking were then shared at further staff forums together with FAQs. Individual outcome discussions were arranged at which each situation was explained in detail, particularly around the spot and range approach.
The Outcome
This range around the median enabled three essential objectives to be realised.
The first objective was a smooth and affordable transition to the new framework, ensuring that 98% of people transitioned across without any pay detriment either way.
The second objective was that the Academy now has a flexible pay framework linked to the market that enables them to attract and retain staff. It has also led to a far higher percentage of staff having a degree of potential pay headroom as opposed to their historic incremental system.
The third objective was that, as an outcome of this position, contract consultations were conducted in a far more positive light as individuals could clearly see that the first iteration of a new culture was positive and, therefore, they are more inclined to buy into the new terms and conditions on offer.
Redhill Academy Trust continues to grow with a fair and transparent pay and grading structure in place to ensure legislative compliance and objective decisions about pay and progression. Having built a deep understanding of their organisational structure and culture, we continue to support with Job Evaluation and ad hoc benchmarking data for support roles across their Multi-Academy Trust.
Skip to content