20 Years in Pay and Reward: A Journey Through Shifting Times and Trends
The landscape of pay and reward has evolved significantly over the past two decades, shaped by economic upheavals, societal shifts, and transformative global events. As we celebrate Turning Point’s 20-year anniversary, our CEO, Peter Brauer, looks back at the key milestones and moments that have defined the journey.
The Beginning
2005 was a year of transition, both politically and socially. Tony Blair was into his third term, about to pass the buck to Gordon Brown, just in time for the global financial crisis in 2008!
Turning Point became self-aware in this year and the UK was starting to question the New Labour bounce, the shine taken off it by the Iraq war.
The Equality Act was not yet a Bill, but the Equal Pay and Anti-discrimination Acts did exist. Gender pay reporting was a pipedream, although the Single Status Agreement, signed in 1997, was starting to impact reward. For those with long memories, the Single Status Agreement was one of the first significant steps to remove gender bias from reward strategies, although compliance challenges were frequent. Conversations with line managers were often filled with debates on why pay equity seemed so elusive.
Region pay rates and London weighting, driven by the Big Bang in the financial markets a decade previously, became a popular mechanism to differentiate pay levels along with the introduction of the union agreed NJC job evaluation scheme.
Our client base was predominantly local authorities and housing associations – with the Housing Act 1996 setting the way for local authorities to offload the building, repair and management of their ageing housing stock. RSLs (Registered Social Landlords) quickly became very diverse organisations, not just delivering housing solutions but becoming more embedded in the social fabric of their communities. They were offering a 360-degree social support solution from drug and alcohol projects, through domestic abuse and childcare options. RSLs also started to build (develop) new properties for both rent and sale – calling on new skill sets from widening comparator groups.
Global Banking Crisis
With the storm clouds of a global banking crisis looming in 2008 – driven by the subprime mortgage crisis, everything came to a shuddering halt. Budgets needed to be cut. Borrowing became very difficult, investment stopped, and the world held its breath as huge banking names came tumbling down – driven by the seizure of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac in the USA.
Reward trends started being driven by cost cutting, restructures and redundancies. Companies looked to the market to understand how all this activity would impact their ability to reward their people.
Beyond 2011, the world started to recover and through the subsequent years in the UK up to 2016, we saw a steady return to normal as organisations returned to a market anchor pay rate informed by multiple sectors.
It was no boom, but the general feeling of global recovery made the employment market warm up and tech roles started to gain their (still current) market value.
Brexit
In the UK, we then had the Brexit vote which had an immediate effect on European based UK company workers effectively taking a 20% hit on their earnings and sterling collapsed against the euro.
The resulting exodus of European workers left the hospitality, care and construction sectors looking for headcount in a market that suddenly lost a large percentage of its traditional workforce. Tie this exodus in with the increasing National Minimum Wage planned as well as actual increases, and a perfect storm was brewing.
How could employers differentiate themselves in a highly competitive market when costs were constrained by contractual agreements linked to delivery? Again, market data was at the fore to inform and support sustainable approaches that would attract and retain headcount and talent.
All this needed to be viewed with the added dynamic of Gen Z and their vision of multiple work options in their careers, no longer looking for a job for life.
Employee Value Proposition
How could organisations make that difference? Enter the Employee Value Proposition – the added value to offer and attract people to stay in one place for more than a few months.
2016 to 2019 saw the market adjusting to this impact, just in time for a global pandemic.
Global Pandemic
Now things got really interesting! The pandemic and its resulting lockdown drove a revolution in working styles that remain with us to this day.
Many senior executives I spoke with expressed that, in terms of work-life balance and mental wellbeing, ‘the genie is out of the bottle.’
The traditional 9-to-5, Monday-to-Friday office-based role, once the norm, became nearly an exception, requiring reward options to flex to match the new reality.
Alongside this shift in working styles came a rapid push toward digitalisation, creating an entirely new market. ‘Full stack’ tech professionals became highly sought after, and pay rates skyrocketed. Meanwhile, hospitality roles followed the exodus from the city to rural hotspots, driving up local pay rates whilst city centre venues closed – some of which have yet to reopen.
The backend of 2020 saw the hottest market we have experienced in our 20-year life span. Companies battled with each other to employ those individuals who wanted to return to work, and some sectors saw base pay rates double overnight. HGV drivers, many of whom had either retired or left for home after Brexit, became hot property as the world came to terms with the new norm.
Cost of Living Crisis
When Russia annexed Crimea in 2014, the world barely reacted. However, when Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022, it swiftly disrupted oil, gas, and grain supplies to the Western world, prompting a stronger response. The focus shifted to the massive impact of soaring fuel costs and their ripple effects on food production and global logistics.
In the UK, cost of living indices surged above 15%, and interest rates rose for the first time since 2010. As a result, mortgage rates climbed, and the employment market cooled rapidly, with people prioritising job security with current employers over the uncertainty of new opportunities.
Those employers that had held their nerve during the immediate post Covid period and maintained their pay frameworks could pat themselves on the back, whilst others started to conduct the inevitable restructuring driven by contracting markets.
2025 and Beyond
As I write in 2025 with a reflective eye, the enduring constants of reward over the past 20 years have been job levelling, market pay rates, and a fully costed pay approach that resonates with your people. This creates a view of progression and development, demonstrates respect and value to the workforce, and is affordable in the long term.
Let’s not forget the Equality Act 2010 and the upcoming EU pay transparency regulations which will continue to influence how businesses structure their pay practices.
Looking ahead, we can only anticipate more changes and challenges—but with thoughtful, data-driven strategies, organisations will be equipped to navigate whatever comes next.
Still, at least we have a set of level-headed, emotionally aware individuals in power across the world – what could possibly go wrong!
Skip to content